In defense of book blogging

Mabel, of Maple and a Quill, encountered a pretty savage shot across the bow aimed at book blogs and book bloggers this weekend, and fired back a salvo as polite as it is devastating in defense of what we do.  I’d talk at more length about why the critic she’s responding to—and a lot of critics like him—are clearly both badly informed about the breadth of the world of book blogging, and astoundingly chauvinist in the ways they think and talk about book bloggers (“knitting circles”?  Wow, and I thought no man was left alive who had been a member of a Victorian gentlemen’s club.  He must think those suffragettes are outrageous).  But honestly, Mabel has said it much more articulately and more stirringly than I think I can muster, so go give her essay a read.

Need more incentive?  This, I think, is the heart of her piece: “As one of the leeches of literature, I feel inspired to speak. I am no literary critic, but I am an intelligent, keen, earnest, curious, and certainly legitimate member of the literary conversation, and I daresay I live in a society that is both aggressive and gentle; both analytical and emotive; both critical and appreciative; both male and female. I do not write to tear apart literature, but to learn from it, and to share my tattered thoughts, which are very much a work in progress.”  Amen to that, Mabel—amen.

Advertisements

5 comments on “In defense of book blogging

  1. Mabel says:

    Thanks, James. I felt I had to say something on this one. (Happy Holidays!) 🙂

  2. Nerija S. says:

    Amen, indeed! These anti-book-blog rants are honestly getting funnier and funnier. And what’s wrong with making literary discussion a play date? Gasp! People having fun with books? Talking about their…feelings? This is Most Unorthodox!

  3. Amy says:

    Couldn’t agree more. Really, we aren’t allowed to talk about books unless it’s on a scholarly level? We can’t share our responses and reactions? We must keep it inside unless we have PhD’s in literature? Wow. Thanks for sharing this, James and Mabel.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s